Opening statements end, witnesses take stand in trial of Naresh Bhatt, Virginia man accused of killing wife
Opening arguments end and witnesses take stand in Naresh Bhatt’s Virginia trial
Two witnesses took the stand after opening arguments Wednesday in the trial for Naresh Bhatt, a Virginia man accused of killing and dismembering his wife.
MANASSAS, Va. - A jury has been seated and opening statements wrapped up on Wednesday in the trial of Naresh Bhatt, the Manassas man accused of murdering and dismembering his wife, Mamta Kafle Bhatt.
Two witnesses took the stand on Wednesday; Mamta Bhatt's former work supervisor who called for a welfare check, and the Manassas Park Police officer who responded to conduct the check.
What we know:
Naresh Bhatt, who has remained in custody since his August 2024 arrest, faces charges of murder as well as concealing and defiling a dead body. The trial got underway Monday in Prince William County Circuit Court before Judge Kimberly Irving.
The case began Aug. 1, 2024, when Mamta Kafle Bhatt, a 28-year-old pediatric nurse failed to report for her shift at UVA Health Prince William Medical Center. Officers conducted a welfare check at the couple's Heather Court home the following day at the request of her co-workers. While Naresh Bhatt initially told police he did not believe his wife was missing, family and friends insisted she would not abandon her infant daughter.
Authorities officially declared her involuntarily missing on Aug. 5, 2024.
READ MORE | Virginia community marks 2 years since disappearance of Mamta Bhatt ahead of October murder trial
Investigators arrested Bhatt on Aug. 22, 2024, after discovering large bloodstains in the primary bedroom and bathroom of the couple's home. According to court documents, investigators seized a power saw containing hair fragments from the home and gathered evidence indicating Bhatt visited multiple trash disposal sites.
Mamta Kafle Bhatt's body has never been recovered.
Jury selection
Out of 170 potential jurors, 16 and one alternate were sworn in Wednesday, including six men and 11 women.
Attorneys made it clear that this would be a case of circumstantial evidence, as Mamta Bhatt’s remains have not been found. They also warned that jurors will be hearing a lot of graphic details in the coming weeks.
Some new details were revealed during the voir dire process, when the judge and attorneys questioned potential jurors to find out who may be biased.
RELATED: Jury selection resumes for Naresh Bhatt, Virginia man accused of killing, dismembering missing wife
During that time, the lead defense attorney said jurors would hear how Naresh Bhatt grew up in extreme poverty in Nepal during a time of political violence. The defense attorney asked jurors if they would be comfortable hearing information like that.
There was also a great deal of attention given to English, with the jury pool facing questions about whether anyone would have a hard time understanding scientific or technical words in English or whether anyone had any issue with English not being a first language for the suspect and some of the witnesses who would be called to testify.
The jury was also warned about discussing the case in waiting.
Opening Arguments
During opening statements, the prosecution brought up how the couple was dealing with marital strife, how Naresh Bhatt gave different stories when asked where his wife was and the blood evidence police collected in the couple’s home.
The prosecution also mentioned a Sawzall power saw that Naresh Bhatt allegedly gave to a gardner as payment for about $40 worth of yard work. The prosecutor said the landscaper learned about what happened to Mamta Bhatt and went to police with the tool. Blood was allegedly found inside. The prosecution further questioned how a mother could leave their infant child.
"This trial is going to prove how this defendant was living the American dream, and how it ultimately ended as a nightmare when the defendant kills his wife, Mamta Kafle, defiles her body, and then conceals her dead body, never to be found again," said Deputy Commonwealth’s Attorney Matthew Sweet.
The defense argued that the prosecution will not be able to answer all that happened, and said it’s the jury’s job to decide whether they do prove guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.
"There is a sort of black hole at the time of Mamta Kafle Bhatt’s disappearance, and it’s a hole where evidence should be," said Chief Public Defender Tracey Lennox. "The hole that the government will not be able to fill for you. They’re going to try to fill the gap with ideas and speculations and guesses, but not with actual fact. There will be things at the conclusion of the evidence that you just won’t know."
Court will resume on Thursday at 9 a.m.
The Source: Information in this article comes from Prince William County court proceedings and previous FOX 5 reporting.