Internet searches revealed on Day 13 of Naresh Bhatt murder trial
Naresh Bhatt trial Day 13: Disturbing searches, trash compactor video shown
Jurors in the trial of Naresh Bhatt reviewed chilling search queries and surveillance footage presented by prosecutors regarding the disappearance of his wife, Mamta Kafle Bhatt. Digital evidence revealed searches about what happens when a spouse disappears, meat cutting tools, and even donating an infant, alongside video showing Bhatt dumping bags into trash compactors while wearing gloves. The defense challenged the findings, arguing the lack of exact timestamps prevents investigators from determining when or why the searches were made.
MANASSAS, Va. - Jurors in the murder trial of Naresh Bhatt were presented with digital forensic evidence on Wednesday, revealing internet searches conducted months before his wife, Mamta Kafle Bhatt, disappeared in 2024.
What we know:
Bhatt, who has remained in custody since his August 2024 arrest, is accused of murdering his wife and dismembering her body. He faces charges of first-degree murder, concealing a dead body and defiling a dead body. Mamta's body has not been recovered.
On Day 13 of the trial, Katherine Zaimis of the Prince William County Police Digital Forensics Unit walked the jury through Google searches recovered from Naresh’s digital history. According to forensic investigators, Naresh’s internet searches in March 2024, months before Mamta’s disappearance, included "what happens if a spouse disappears" and "can I divorce if wife lost."
Investigators also discovered searches regarding tools and sharp objects, including meat cutters, knife sharpeners at Dollar Tree and hand saws for cutting wood. Other searches included questions about melatonin dosing for both adults and children, travel from Delhi, India, to Dulles, and "can I change my mind after selling car at CarMax."
RELATED: Cell phone, vehicle tracking data presented in Naresh Bhatt murder trial
Zaimis testified that Naresh also searched whether he could give away the couple's one-year-old daughter, asking: "can I donate my baby to my friend?" The search history further included inquiries related to applying for a baby passport.
In addition to the internet searches, investigators revealed that Naresh had changed Mamta’s contact name in his phone to "BAD MEMORY" accompanied by a running emoji, and had messages discussing another woman. Testimony also showed that he made eight outgoing calls to his wife after she vanished.
Defense pushes back
The defense pushed back against the digital findings, challenging the reliability of how the evidence is interpreted. During cross-examination, the defense pointed out that many of the searches lacked timestamps, meaning investigators could not verify the exact time, chronological order, physical location or underlying motive behind when and why the searches occurred.
Jurors were also presented with testimony from a video enhancement expert, who reviewed footage showing Naresh inside his home and at several trash compactors wearing gloves while dumping small bags.
The backstory:
The trial stems from the disappearance of Mamta Kafle Bhatt, who failed to report for work as an employee at UVA Health Prince William Medical Center on Aug. 1, 2024. Co-workers requested a welfare check at the couple’s Heather Court home the following day after she missed two consecutive shifts. While relatives and friends insisted she would never abandon her baby daughter, Naresh initially told responding officers that he did not believe his wife was missing and claimed he had last seen her on July 29.
Bhatt filed an official missing persons report on Aug. 5, 2024, telling officers his wife had threatened to leave and had suggested divorce. Later that day, authorities classified her disappearance as involuntary.
READ MORE | Mother, friend of Mamta Kafle Bhatt testify in her husband Naresh Bhatt’s murder trial
Bhatt was arrested on Aug. 22, 2024, after investigators uncovered extensive bloodstains inside the home's primary bedroom and bathroom. Court records show authorities recovered a power saw containing hair fragments and gathered evidence linking Bhatt to multiple trash disposal facilities.
On Tuesday, prosecutors called an FBI expert who testified about vehicle tracking and cellphone records. The data generally placed the couple in the same vicinity, with three exceptions, including one instance where Mamta’s phone remained stationary while Bhatt’s vehicle traveled to Chantilly. Neighbors from three separate homes also testified Tuesday that Bhatt never told them his wife was missing.
Proceedings will resume Thursday for Day 14 of the trial.
The Source: Information in this article comes from court proceedings and original FOX 5 DC reporting.