Former roommate testifies as prosecution highlights alibi timeline in Naresh Bhatt murder trial
New evidence introduced in Naresh Bhatt murder trial
New evidence was introduced in Naresh Bhatt's murder trial.
MANASSAS, Va. - The prosecution picked up where they left off in the Naresh Bhatt murder trial Monday as it moved into Day 8. Prosecutors presented store surveillance footage and testimony from a former roommate from a former roommate to poke holes in the defendant's timeline.
What we know:
Naresh Bhatt, 39, is accused of murdering and dismembering his 28-year-old wife, Mamta Kafle Bhatt, in 2024.
In the third week of the trial, jurors heard testimony from Nadia Navarro, who lived with Mamta in an apartment on Wickersham Way in Falls Church from the fall of 2021 to early winter 2022.
Navarro testified that Naresh Bhatt was looking for someone to share a room with his wife, who was arriving in the United States for the first time. Naresh Bhatt offered a heavily discounted room in exchange for helping Mamta with her English and showing her around. Navarro learned in court that Bhatt owned the property.
RELATED: Bedroom carpet presented as suspected blood evidence in Naresh Bhatt murder trial
Navarro described being close with Mamta and testified that Mamta spoke to her about her marriage. However, after Navarro was asked whether she had witnessed physical contact between the couple and began to recount a potential incident between them, defense objections prevented the questions from being answered.
Navarro told the court she had made plans to spend time with Mamta in July 2024 and missed a phone call from her on July 28 while hospitalized. Days later, Navarro learned through a Facebook message that Mamta was missing.
Navarro testified that she immediately tried calling Mamta back several times with no answer. She described the silence as "really strange" and "weird" because Mamta was a "reliable and consistent person" who was not difficult to reach.
Store surveillance footage
The testimony was accompanied by surveillance footage tracking Bhatt’s purchases and movements in the days surrounding his wife’s disappearance.
On Friday, security footage was shown of Bhatt purchasing knives.
On Monday prosecutors introduced Walmart surveillance video from July 31, 2024. The footage captured Bhatt buying multiple cleaning agents and air fresheners, including disinfecting wipes, 409 rug cleaner, Febreze plug-in oils, air fresheners and a car tree air freshener.
July 31 is the date Bhatt told police in body camera footage that he last saw his wife, claiming he had stepped out of their home to run errands at a Lidl supermarket before returning to spend time with her.
RELATED: Mother, friend of Mamta Kafle Bhatt testify in her husband Naresh Bhatt’s murder trial
Prosecutors challenged that narrative with security footage from a Manassas Lidl, which placed Bhatt at the store on July 30, the day before he claimed to have visited. The footage showed Bhatt visiting the store twice on July 30, once in the morning and once in the evening. During the evening trip, Bhatt purchased "extra strong" garbage bags.
Prosecutors have also begun introducing Flock camera images into evidence, which law enforcement used to track the movements of Bhatt's blue Tesla. Additional evidence regarding the vehicle tracking is expected in the coming days.
The backstory:
Bhatt, who has remained in custody since his arrest in August 2024, faces charges of first-degree murder, concealing a dead body, and defiling a dead body.
The case began when Mamta failed to report for her shift at UVA Health Prince William Medical Center on Aug. 1, 2024. Her co-workers requested a welfare check at the couple's Heather Court home the following day after she missed two consecutive shifts.
Bhatt initially told responding officers he did not believe his wife was missing, claiming he last saw her on July 29. However, family and friends insisted she would never abandon her infant daughter.
Bhatt called police to file a missing persons report on Aug. 5, 2024. Investigators initially lacked information suggesting she was in danger, as Bhatt told an officer she threatened to disappear and raised the possibility of a divorce. However, authorities officially declared her involuntarily missing on Aug. 5, 2024.
Investigators arrested Bhatt on Aug. 22, 2024, after discovering large bloodstains in the primary bedroom and bathroom. According to court documents, investigators seized a power saw containing hair fragments from the residence and gathered evidence indicating Bhatt visited multiple trash disposal sites. Her body has not been recovered.
The Source: Information in this article comes from the Associated Press, court proceedings and previous FOX 5 reporting.