Testimony in Naresh Bhatt murder trial highlights child’s condition, local garbage operations

Testimony in the murder trial of Naresh Bhatt reached its ninth day on Tuesday. Prosecutors called multiple witnesses to the stand to build their case against the defendant, who is accused of murdering and dismembering his wife, Mamta Kafle Bhatt. 

Court proceedings Tuesday afternoon featured testimony from the Bhatt family babysitter, a local trash disposal business owner and a former co-worker and friend of Mamta.

Babysitter testifies about child’s condition

Amanda Jiron-Perez, the babysitter for the couple's child, testified about interactions with Naresh Bhatt following Mamta's disappearance. Jiron-Perez said that after July 9, Naresh became the sole parent dropping off and picking up the child.

She told the jury that Naresh dropped the child off un-bathed and wearing stained clothing. She further testified that Naresh forced his way into her home without consent, peering out the window and looking around the room.

RELATED: Former roommate testifies as prosecution highlights alibi timeline in Naresh Bhatt murder trial

Garbage operations

John Poague, owner of Patriot Disposal, which services the Manassas Park area, testified about  the logistics of waste management. Poague described handling up to 2,000 tons of garbage daily across 12-hour shifts.

When asked about detecting specific odors at a transfer facility, Poague noted that trash carries a general unpleasant odor mixed with chemicals and baby diapers, making it impossible to single out specific smells such as a rotting carcass. He further explained that facilities forbid the screening of trash upon arrival and noted that a request to sort trash on a Wednesday, the scheduled service day for Manassas Park, would be "very expensive."

Prosecutors claim that Bhatt discarded his wife's body in various garbage compactors across Northern Virginia.

Co-worker details workplace stress

Sunita Pasnet Thapa is a co-worker and friend who trained Mamta as a nurse at Inova. Pasnet Thapa said she viewed Mamta as a younger sister or daughter. She testified about Mamta's state of mind toward the end of her pregnancy.

Pasnet Thapa said Mamta appeared fearful and under significant pressure regarding her job security.

Pasnet Thapa also detailed her initial interaction with Naresh at the hospital shortly after Mamta gave birth.

She recalled advising Mamta against using rash cream on a one-day-old newborn, explaining that vernix naturally lubricates the skin.

According to Pasnet Thapa, Naresh responded by asking her, "What kind of nurse are you?" a remark she found insulting.

"Naresh told me, ‘What kind of nurse are you,'" Pasnet Thapa said. "I felt that was kind of insulting saying that to Mamta and Mamta considered me a big sister."

The backstory:

Naresh has remained in custody since his arrest in August 2024. He faces charges of first-degree murder, concealing a dead body and defiling a dead body.

The case began when Mamta failed to report for her shift at UVA Health Prince William Medical Center on Aug. 1, 2024. Her co-workers requested a welfare check at the couple's Heather Court home the following day after she missed two consecutive shifts.

Bhatt initially told responding officers he did not believe his wife was missing, claiming he last saw her on July 29. However, family and friends insisted she would never abandon her infant daughter.

Bhatt called police to file a missing persons report on Aug. 5, 2024. Investigators initially lacked information suggesting she was in danger, as Bhatt told an officer she threatened to disappear and raised the possibility of a divorce. However, authorities officially declared her involuntarily missing on Aug. 5, 2024.

Investigators arrested Bhatt on Aug. 22, 2024, after discovering large bloodstains in the primary bedroom and bathroom. According to court documents, investigators seized a power saw containing hair fragments from the residence and gathered evidence indicating Bhatt visited multiple trash disposal sites. 

Her body has not been recovered.

The trial is scheduled to resume Wednesday at 9 a.m.

The Source: Information in this article comes from the Associated Press, court proceedings and previous FOX 5 reporting.  

NewsManassasVirginiaVirginia Crime