Bedroom carpet presented as suspected blood evidence in Naresh Bhatt murder trial

Prosecutors presented a massive piece of physical evidence in their case against Naresh Bhatt as the trial resumed on Thursday. The Northern Virginia man is accused of murdering and dismembering his wife, Mamta Kafle Bhatt, in 2024.

What we know:

With help from prosecutors, Prince William County Police investigator Joseph Restino rolled out an approximately 8-by-10-foot section of carpet directly before the jury.

Restino testified that he cut the carpet from the bedroom of the couple's home. The jury was shown evidence photos of a suspected bloodstain found underneath the carpeting in an area where forensic testing had previously produced a positive reaction to the chemical reagent Bluestar.

RELATED: Body-cam video, conflicting timeline put Naresh Bhatt under scrutiny on Day 5 of Virginia murder trial

Restino testified that the carpet presented in court was the same section that illuminated during chemical screening for possible traces of blood. At the police department office, Restino removed a sample to send to a laboratory for DNA testing and performed a preliminary swab that turned pink, indicating a positive result for blood. Restino told the court that he would not expect to see such a positive reaction inside a bedroom.

The jury also heard testimony about evidence recovered from the master bathroom, where Restino said he removed the bathtub during evidence collection. Investigators discovered a reddish-brown stain beneath where the bottom of the tub sat, leading them to believe that a large volume of blood had seeped through the bathtub caulking.

Defense challenges findings

The defense challenged the forensic findings. Assistant Defense Attorney Laurel Rodewald questioned Bluestar expert Nancy Sulinski-Steffens, asking whether a positive reaction could reveal how or why a substance ended up where it did.

Sulinski-Steffens acknowledged the limitations of the chemical test, testifying that while Bluestar is an investigative tool used by law enforcement, it does not confirm the presence of blood.

The backstory:

Bhatt, who has remained in custody since his arrest in August 2024, faces charges of first-degree murder, concealing a dead body, and defiling a dead body. Mamta Kafle Bhatt's body has never been recovered.

The investigation began after Mamta failed to show up for her shift at UVA Health Prince William Medical Center on Aug. 1, 2024. Her co-workers requested a welfare check at the couple's Northern Virginia home after she missed two consecutive shifts.

When responding officers initially arrived, Bhatt claimed he did not believe his wife was missing and said he had last seen her on July 29. Friends and family, however, insisted she would never abandon her infant daughter.

On Aug. 5, 2024, Bhatt contacted police to file a missing persons report, telling an officer his wife had threatened to disappear and mentioning a possible divorce. Authorities officially declared her involuntarily missing that same day.

RELATED: Suspected blood evidence, recorded interview shared during day 6 of Naresh Bhatt’s murder trial

Investigators took Bhatt into custody on Aug. 22, 2024, following the discovery of large bloodstains inside the primary bedroom and bathroom. According to court records, detectives seized a power saw containing hair fragments from the home and uncovered evidence that Bhatt had visited multiple trash disposal sites.

Thursday's carpet presentation followed a full day of forensic testimony on Wednesday, when prosecutors displayed video footage and images of suspected blood evidence to the jury.

That evidence included testimony from a former Prince William County forensics investigator regarding trace blood reactions on the bedroom carpet, photographs of small brownish-red stains swabbed from a bathroom windowsill and pictures of zip ties, cleaning products, and Mamta's wallet containing three unexpired credit cards.

Prosecutors also began introducing cell phone records alongside data connected to Bhatt’s Tesla.

Court will resume on Monday, Oct. 19.

The Source: Information in this article comes from the Associated Press, court proceedings and previous FOX 5 reporting.  

NewsManassasVirginia Crime